Meta Story

Me: I will tell you an idea for a story. Could you write it?

Meta: I'd love to write a story based on your idea. Please go ahead and share it with me. I'll do my best to bring your concept to life with my words. Don't worry if your idea is rough or unfinished – I'll help develop it into a compelling narrative. What's your idea? Is it a sci-fi adventure, a romantic tale, a mystery, or something else? Share it, and let's create a story together!

Me: Okay. The story is about a father and his daughter. One day the daughter goes to cinema after lying to her father that she is going to school. However, the father finds out the truth. 

Now, you should write a sentence that's like an infinite loop. Here is the idea. 

1) The father knows that the daughter went to cinema.
2) The daughter knows that his father knows the truth. However, she thinks that the father doesn't know the fact that she knows that the father knows about her cinema going.
3) But, the father knows that the daughter knows the fact that he has found about her cinema going. 

It should go on like this. The ending sentence of the story should suggest that this loop will go on forever leaving the reader in awe wondering which one of these is ahead of the other.

Meta: Here's a story based on your idea:

As the daughter slipped into the cinema, she thought she had gotten away with the perfect lie. She had told her father she was heading to school, but the allure of the big screen was too great to resist. But, unbeknownst to her, her father had already discovered the truth. The daughter, however, assumed that her father didn't know that she knew he had been caught. Yet, the father was well aware that his daughter knew he had found out about the cinema trip.

But the daughter, in turn, believed that her father didn't know that she knew her father knew. She thought she had covered her tracks well, but her father had been one step ahead all along. And so it went on - the father knowing that the daughter knew he knew, the daughter knowing that the father knew she knew he knew, and the father knowing that the daughter knew he knew she knew he knew... Ad infinitum.

Who was really one step ahead in this endless game of cat and mouse? Was it the father, who seemed to know everything, or the daughter, who thought she was pulling off the perfect deception?

Comments

  1. Anonymous18 September 2024 at 02:22

    ஒரு புறாவை தின்று விட்டு நான் படும் பாடு.. சே.. Likewise, ஒரு படத்திற்கு அவள் பொய்சொல்லி சென்றதால் வாசகர்கள் படும் பாடு 😵‍💫😶

    ReplyDelete
  2. Can't say anonymous18 September 2024 at 03:32

    இது ஏதோ meta எழுதுன கதை மாதிரி தெரியலையே.
    "என்னாதிது!? ஆஹேன்" (சுதாகர்'ஸ் modulation)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Can't say anonymous18 September 2024 at 22:31


    *Metastory breakdown:* Part I


    (Note: This piece of analysis is written and submitted after doing only very few re-readings {Hence there will be chances for errors} considering the fact that reading this again and again and checking the facts will fry the brain cells.)

    The story 'ends?' when the father comes to know that his daughter knows that he knew that she was aware that her father has found out about her cinema-going.

    This story has multiple layers. Let's introduce three more characters to make our brains comprehend this complexly built story.

    *Daughter's POV:*

    She waves bye to her father as usual when she leaves to school. Inside she feels nervous. Instead of going to school she goes to cinema along with her friends.

    While she is about to enter the cinema hall holding a small tub of popcorn, she notices a familiar figure in the corridors. It is her father's friend. She immediately hides behind one of her friends and manages to get inside the theatre before he could see her. However she has a doubt whether he would have seen her as they both previously were in each other's vantage point. She is worried whether he would inform her father if at all he has seen her. As her father's friend is a big-mouthed person, she believes that the news will reach her father's ears even before the movie begins.

    The movie gets over and the nervous look on her face says that she hasn't enjoyed the movie. All that kept running in her mind was that her father must have known by now. However, she is quite sure that her father does not know that she knows he knows from his friend.

    *Father's Friend's (FF) POV:*

    FF is surprised to find his friend's school-going daughter in the theatre during school hours. He immediately rings up his friend and informs the matter. The father asks whether his daughter saw him. He replies no as she was on her way to the popcorn counter.


    *Father's POV:*

    The father's phone rings when he is busily attending to the customers at his department store. He is confused to hear his friend saying that the latter saw the former's daughter in the theatre. He confirms it thrice. Even then, he calls his son who is assisting him in the store to go and check in the theatre without him getting noticed by his sister.

    *Son's POV:*

    The son goes to the theatre and waits there till his sister arrives. He chooses a place to wait where he cannot be easily seen. When the show gets over, the theatre door opens and the audience start coming out. His eyes sieve through the crowd and finds his sister. He notices the nervous look on her face and an uneasy and hurried attitude in her walk. He calls his father and informs this.

    *Father's POV:*

    From what his son told him, he deduces that she somehow knew that he knew she was at the theatres.

    *Daughter's POV:*

    As she was heading towards the gate, she notices her brother leaving the premises on his bike. Such a lucky day where she gets to see every familiar person on her stealth mission. Now she knows for sure that her father knows that she knows that her father knew.

    She comes back home with such uneasiness. She does not eat her lunch and refuses to talk to anyone at home.

    *Father's POV:*

    From his son, he learns what happened at the theatre. Later he calls home and learns from his wife that his daughter looks very nervous, angry and cranky. Now he knows that she knows he knows about her cinema-going.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Can't say anonymous18 September 2024 at 22:32

    *Metastory breakdown: * Part II
    Let's fit the story in the given conditions :

    *1) The father knows that the daughter went to cinema.*

    He knows it from his friend.

    *2) The daughter knows that his father knows the truth.*

    She guesses that her father's loud-mouthed friend would have informed her father if at all he had noticed her in the crowd. The chances for noticing her are pretty high. Hence she knows that her father knows the truth.

    * However, she thinks that the father doesn't know the fact that she knows that the father knows about her cinema going.*

    As she saw FF when he was not looking at her and did not make any direct eye contact with FF, she is sure that there are no chances for her father to know that she knows he knows.

    *3) But, the father knows that the daughter knows the fact that he has found about her cinema going.*

    He knows this from the body language as reported to him by his son. Her nervous, hurried, tensed looks confirms this.

    And so it went on -
    *the father knowing that the daughter knew he knew,*

    The nervous attitude reported by the son.

    *the daughter knowing that the father knew she knew he knew, *

    Her brother leaving the premises.

    He will go and describe/narrate what happened to his father. Hence she knows that the father will come to know that she knows about his knowledge of her secret movie venture.

    *and the father knowing that the daughter knew he knew she knew he knew...* Ad infinitum.

    Her behaviour at her home after returning from the theatre.

    Let's analyse this sentence from the end to the beginning:

    She has gone to the movie.

    *he knew*- The father comes to know about it.

    *she knew*- She comes to know that her father found out.

    *he knew*- The father comes to know that she is aware that he has found out about her cinema-going.

    *the daughter knew*-She comes to know that her father knows very well that she has found out that her father has found out about her venture.

    *the father knowing'- The father knows that his daughter is now fully aware about his discovery of her cinema-going and that she has found out about it.

    *Conclusion:*

    Neither of them is truly ahead of each other. They are stuck in a loop of deception and discovery.

    Deception took place only once. The lie. The rest all are discoveries.

    Daughter deceives.

    Father discovers.

    Daughter discovers that the father has discovered.

    Father discovers that the daughter has discovered that he has discovered.

    Daughter discovers that the father has discovered that she has discovered her father's discovery.

    Father discovers that the daughter has discovered the father's discovery that she has discovered her father's discovery.

    Finis.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Venu Murali22 November 2024 at 21:54

      😣😵‍💫😮🙏🏼🙏🏼

      Delete
  5. Can't say anonymous24 September 2024 at 07:58

    Thank you very much for your thoughtful acknowledgement.. Appreciate that you've received it with much understanding..

    After writing the comment, i didn't have the courage to revisit and reread either the original post or the comment completely. It hurts the brain. Till now I'm wondering how i even tried to decipher and wrote it.

    The scarier part of your reply is the second paragraph where you explained what the original idea really is. The scariest part is the first line of 'Titbit' 😱😩

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

எங்களைத் தற்குறிகள் என்று சொல்பவர்களுக்காக.

"தமிழ்நாட்டின் தலைநகரம் சென்னை." "நண்டு படத்தை இயக்கியவர் மகேந்திரன்." மேற்காணும் இரண்டு கூற்றுகளும் உண்மைகள் (facts).   அழகம்பாளையம் தனசேகரிடம் கேட்டாலும் அதைத்தான் சொல்லுவார், அஞ்சானூர் தமிழன்புவிடம் கேட்டாலும் அதைத்தான் சொல்லுவார். (தமிழ்நாட்டின் தலைநகரம் மதுரை என்று தவறாகச் சொல்பவர்களும் இருப்பார்கள். அதுவும் உண்மையில்லை. தலைநகரம் சென்னை என்று தெரிந்தும் ஒருவர் அப்படிச் சொன்னால் அது பொய்.)   இன்னும் இரண்டு கூற்றுகள். "சென்னை ஓர் அழகான ஊர்." "நண்டு  படம் நன்றாக இருக்காது." இந்த இரண்டு கூற்றுகளும் கருத்துகள் (opinions). தனசேகரைப் பொறுத்தவரை சென்னை அழகான ஊராக இருக்கலாம். ஆனால், தமிழன்பு அதை ஓர் அழகற்ற ஊரென நினைக்கலாம்.  அதேபோல்தான் நண்டு படம் குறித்த கருத்தும்.  ... பொதுவாக வாக்குவாதங்களில் தத்தம் கருத்துகளைச் சொல்பவர்கள் செய்யும் தவறுகள் இரண்டு. 1) அவை தம்முடைய கருத்துகள் மட்டுமே என்பதையோ, தன்னுடைய கருத்து என்பதாலேயே அது உண்மையாக இருக்க வேண்டிய அவசியம் இல்லை என்பதையோ ஏற்க மறுப்பது. 2) கருத்துகளை நிறுவ உண்மைகளைச் சொல்லாமல், மேலும் தங்களுடைய கரு...
The Red Pill

என் ஆசிரியர்கள்

ராமசாமி வாத்தியார் அயலூர் ஊராட்சி ஒன்றியத் துவக்கப்பள்ளி, நாமக்கல் பாளையம் - என்ற சொற்றொடரைப் படித்து முடிப்பதற்குள்ளாகவே முழுப் பள்ளிக்கூடத்தையும் சுற்றி வந்து விடலாம்.‌ அவ்வளவு சிறியதுதான் நான் படித்த பள்ளி. அங்கே எங்களுக்குப் பாடம் சொன்ன ஆசிரியர்களில் மூவர் மட்டுமே என் நினைவில் நிற்கிறார்கள். அதில் முதலாமவர் ராமசாமி வாத்தியார்.  அவருக்கு அறுபது வயதுக்கு மேல் இருக்கும். பத்து வயதுக்கும் கீழிருந்த குழந்தைகளுக்கு அறுபது வயது ஆசிரியர் என்பதே எவ்வளவு அழகான சூழ்நிலை! அவருக்கும் எங்களுக்குமான உறவு, ஒரு தாத்தாவுக்கும் பேரப் பிள்ளைகளுக்குமான உறவாகவே இருந்தது.  வெள்ளை வேட்டி சட்டையில்தான் வருவார்; எங்களுடன் சேர்ந்து க்ரிக்கெட் விளையாடுவார்; 'கொல கொலயா முந்திரிக்கா' என்ற விளையாட்டை எங்களுக்கு சொல்லித் தந்தவரும் அவரே.   எவ்வளவு சிரத்தையெடுத்து யோசித்தாலும், அவர் எங்களுக்குப் பாடம் நடத்தியதான நினைவு ஒன்று கூட வரவில்லை. பிறகு என்னதான் செய்வார்? கதைதான். ஒன்று முதல் ஐந்தாம் வகுப்பு வரையிலான குழந்தைகள் அனைவரையும் சேர்த்து மொத்தப் பள்ளியின் மாணவர் எண்ணிக்கையே முப்பதோ நாற்பதோதான் இ...
The Red Pill

நீதி வென்றுகொண்டுதான் இருக்கிறதா?

இப்போது தீர்ப்பு வந்துள்ள ஜெயராஜ் பென்னிக்ஸ் வழக்கை எடுத்துக்கொள்வோம்.  அந்த வழக்கில் குற்றம் நிரூபிக்கப்பட்ட ஒன்பது காவலர்களுக்கும் இரட்டை மரண தண்டனை வழங்கப்பட்டுள்ளது.  இதை வாட்ஸேப் ஸ்டேட்டஸில் பதிவிடும் பலரும் "நீதி வென்றது" என்று பதிவிட்டு வருகிறார்கள்.  முதலில் எதிலெல்லாம் எனக்கு மாற்றுக்கருத்து இல்லை என்பதைச் சொல்லிவிடுகிறேன். தவறு செய்தவர்கள் தண்டிக்கப்பட வேண்டும்.‌ அவ்வாறு தவறு செய்தவர்கள் தண்டிக்கப்படும்‌ போது அது பாராட்டப்பட‌ வேண்டும்.  அதிலே இரண்டாம்‌ கருத்தே இல்லை.  இப்போது தண்டனை என்பதன் நோக்கம் என்ன என்று பார்ப்போம்.  பள்ளிக்குள்ளே குப்பை போட்டால் பத்து ரூபாய் அபராதம் என்று வைத்துக் கொள்வோம். அதன் நோக்கம் பத்து ரூபாயை இழப்பதற்கு அஞ்சி யாரும் குப்பை போடக்கூடாது என்பதேயொழிய, அந்தப் பணத்தை கூலியாட்களுக்குக் கொடுத்து குப்பையை அள்ளிப் போடலாம்‌ என்பதல்ல. இந்த உதாரணத்தில் பிரச்சினை குப்பை இல்லை. குப்பை போட வேண்டும்‌ என்று ஒருவர் மனதில் தோன்றும்‌ எண்ணமே தீர்க்கப்பட வேண்டிய பிரச்சினை. தொடர்ந்து நூறு வருடங்களுக்கு அந்தப் பள்ளியில் தினந்தோறும் பத்து பத்த...
The Red Pill